We send MIDI as fast as is physically possible, maybe that's the difference. Other controllers could be putting a few mSec between messages and we wouldn't be able to notice in most cases. Generally speaking, I find faster = better for MIDI purposes, though.yes this worked for me i had it at 6ms and it was working but i just increased just because its not gonna make a big difference. I guess this will do for now. Thank you for all the help everyone and Ron!
Also your values are correct its the manual of the bigsky MX that are incorrect.
bypass 102
on: 0
off: 127
Last thing just wanted to post here what strymon support sent me back with.
Support:
Like I mentioned, it's something to do with certain MIDI switchers and how the messages are sent out, not so much how the pedal receives them. I'm able to send these same MIDI messages using my DAW and my Morningstar MC6 Pro without any issues, and I know the other support folks have tested other MIDI controllers that don't exhibit the behavior you're seeing as well.
Thanks for the info on the CCs, it's good to know I do actually have it right.